[tab:2022/23]
The Hans Fyfe Trophy is contested by the clubs who lose in the First Round of the Dickie Trophy.
Final
Bon Accord City 2 – 5 AC Mill Inn Academy
Semi-Finals
Bon Accord City 3 – 1 Glentanar Reflex
AC Mill Inn Academy 5 – 2 Monymusk
First Round
Blackburn 1 – 4 Monymusk (AET)
Ellon Amateurs 1 – 4 Bon Accord City
Glentanar Reflex 2 – 0 West End United
University Colts 0 – 4 AC Mill Inn Academy
[tab:2019/20]
Final
Jesus House v Glendale
Semi-Finals
Jesus House 3 – 2 Theologians
BSFC 2 – 3 Glendale
First Round
BSFC 3 – 0 University Strollers
Glentanar Reflex 3 – 4 Glendale
Middlefield Wasps 0 – 4 Theologians
[tab:2018/19]
Final
Cammachmore 1 – 4 FC Polska
Semi-Finals
University Strollers v Cammachmore – University Strollers removed from tournament
FC Polska 5 – 2 Aboyne
Quarter-Finals
Cammachmore 5 – 0 Grammar FP’s
Ferryhill 1 – 2 University Strollers
Lads Club Amateurs 2 – 3 Aboyne
Stonehaven Athletic 3 – 7 FC Polska
First Round
Abergeldie 3 – 5 University Strollers
Cammachmore 2 – 0 West End United
FC Polska 6 – 3 Colony Park
Kemnay Youth 3 – 3 Aboyne (AET), Aboyne won 5-4 on penalties
Lads Club Amateurs 6 – 2 Middlefield Wasps
St Marnans 0 – 2 Grammar FP’s
[tab:2017/18]
Final
St Marnans 2 – 1 Great Western United
Semi-Finals
FC Polska 0 – 5 St Marnans
Great Western United 5 – 3 Powis (AET)
Quarter-Finals
Aboyne 1 – 2 St Marnans
FC Polska 4 – 3 Colony Park
Feughside 2 – 3 Great Western United
Powis 4 – 0 Kemnay Amateurs
[tab:2016/17]
Final
Jesus House 1 – 9 Don Athletic
Semi-Final
Grammmar FP’s 1 – 1 Jesus House (AET), Jesus House won 4-2 on penalties
Huntly Amateurs 1 – 6 Don Athletic
First Round
Aboyne 4 – 5 Grammar FP’s
Highland Hotel 0 – 4 Don Athletic
Jesus House 2 – 1 Kemnay Youth
[tab:2015/16]
Final
Glendale XI 6 – 2 Turriff Thistle
Semi-Finals
Fintray Thistle 4 – 5 Glendale XI (AET)
Turriff Thistle 4 – 3 Lads Club Amateurs (AET)
First Round
Aboyne 1 – 2 Fintray Thistle
Glendale XI 3 – 1 Highland Hotel
Lads Club Amateurs 3 – 1 Colony Park (AET)
[tab:2014/15]
Final
Formartine United 0 – 2 Westhill
Semi-Finals
Formartine United 10 – 3 Summerhill
Burghmuir 0 – 2 Westhill (AET)
Quarter-Finals
AFC Murdos 1 -4 Formartine United
Burghmuir 7 – 3 Monymusk
Summerhill 2 – 1 Torry United
Westhill 2 – 1 Bon Accord City
First Round
Bon Accord City 6 – 1 JS XI
McTeagle 2 – 3 Burghmuir
Middlefield Wasps 1 – 5 Westhill
Torry United w.o.- scr. Glendale XI
[tab:2013/14]
Final
Continental 0 – 4 Granite City
Semi-Finals
Granite City 3 – 0 Banchory Amateurs
Monymusk 1 – 2 Continental (AET)
Quarter-Finals
Continental 2 – 1 McTeagle
Scotstown Rovers 1 – 2 Monymusk
Torry United 2 – 3 Banchory Amateurs
Westhill 5 – 6 Granite City (AET)
First Round
Banchory Amateurs 4 – 1 Aboyne
Torry United 2 – 0 Stonehaven Athletic
[tab:2012/13]
Final
Glentanar Reflex 2 – 0 Ellon Thistle
Semi-Finals
Dee Amateurs 0 – 2 Glentanar Reflex
Banchory Amateurs 0 – 4 Ellon Thistle
Quarter-Finals
Banchory 3 – 2 BSFC
Glentanar Reflex 5 – 4 Newburgh Thistle
Theologians 1 – 8 Ellon Thistle
Summerhill FC 0 – 1 Dee Amateurs
First Round
Continental 4 – 6 Summerhill
Glentanar Reflex 3 – 0 Fintray Thistle
Monymusk 1 – 6 Dee Amateurs
[tab:END]